Timothy C. Hain, MD
Page last modified: December 27, 2015
Saccades are rapid eye movements. This page is about too-slow saccades. Follow this link the general "saccade" page.
The screen shot above shows mildly slowed horizontal saccades in a patient with Parkinsonism. The main sequence (bottom left) shows velocities below normal for all sizes of saccadic eye movements. Saccades are slowed in both directions, and latencies are slightly prolonged (on average).
Also see Leigh/Zee 2015, table 13-3.
Saccades may be too slow, too fast, or have substantially different velocities in one eye or direction than the other. Saccadic slowing is diagnosed when mean saccadic velocity for a particular amplitude is less than the lower fifth percentile of normal. Table 3 lists causes of slow saccades (from Hain, 1993).
When saccadic slowing is observed, drug ingestion should be the first consideration. Anticonvulsants, sedatives and sedating antidepressants are the most common culprits. Saccades can be slowed as much as 50% when subjects become drowsy. If the patient is wide awake and not taking a centrally acting medication, then the alternative diagnoses in table 3 should be considered.
Subcategorizing saccadic disorders by their directional pattern: global saccadic paresis
In some disorders, subtleties of the pattern of saccadic slowing will allow one to further narrow down the list of diagnostic possibilities. One should try to judge whether the slowing involves all saccades, or just horizontal or vertical saccades. Metabolic conditions, such as drug ingestion and drowsiness, cause global saccadic paresis. Most degenerative conditions of the central nervous system that are accompanied by slow saccades; such as cerebellar degenerations, Huntington's chorea, and the chronic progressive external ophthalmoplegias also cause a similar global pattern of slowing. Miller Fisher syndrome, characterized by the triad of opthalmoplegia, ataxia and areflexia is another example. Similarly, brainstem ischemia associated with cardiac surgery occasionally causes a global saccadic paresis (Eggers et al, 2008).
Supplemental material on the site DVD: Video of Progressive External Ophthalmoplegia. This patient carried diagnosis of Kearns-Sayre syndrome. Note that while head moves, eyes do not counter-rotate.
Selective deficits in vertical saccades.
On the other hand, several disorders affect vertical saccades and horizontal saccades differentially. The figure above shows saccades from the same patient with Parkinsonism. Downward saccades are slower than upward saccades as well as of longer latency. Disorders which affect vertical saccades to a greater extent than horizontal saccades include disorders of the midbrain, such as progressive supranuclear palsy (PSP, see figure and movie below), and the ocular muscle involvement typical of thyroid disease.
ALS has also been reported to have slowed vertical saccades (Averbuch Heller et al, 1998), see here for more information. Another helpful point that may assist in identification of PSP and related disorders is constriction of range. Examples of disorders which affect horizontal saccades to a greater extent than vertical saccades include focal lesions of the pons such as internuclear ophthalmoplegia, sixth nerve palsy, and in disorders of the lateral and medial ocular muscles.
|Slow downward saccades in a patient with PSP. These were recorded with a scleral eye coil.|
Supplemental material on the site DVD: Video of slow vertical saccades in patient with PSP (10 meg)
Selective deficits in horizontal saccadesDisorders which impair horizontal saccades to a much greater extent than vertical sacades are very rare - -they include brainstem damage associated with pontine hemorrhage (bleeding) or so-far unlocalized effects of cardiac surgery (Vaughn et al, 2008).
Deficits that involve particular eyes or inward vs outward
In internuclear opthalmoplegia, for horizontal movements, the adducting eye is slowed while the abducting eye typically has normal velocity and has a nystagmus. This is covered in much more detail below under the heading of asymmetrical saccadic slowing. For vertical eye movements, the MLF appears to primarily carry posterior canal signals and anterior canal derived eye movements are spared (Cremer et al, 1999). Breaks in binocular fusion may occur in patients with INO (Mills et al, 2008).
Ocular myasthenia may cause weakness of all ocular muscles, or be restricted to individual muscles. Thus, the horizontal-vertical distinction does not help in the diagnosis. Rather, the diagnosis is usually made via observation of fluctuation of ocular alignment from minute to minute, restriction of eye movement to the central range, and post-saccadic drift (see following section on post-saccadic drift for an example). Myasthenics may also develop a progressive slowing of saccades over time, due to fatigue (Spooner and Baloh, 1979). Ocular myasthenia is usually associated with ptosis and ocular findings are usually affected by small amounts of intravenous edrophonium (the "tensilon" test), but positive ocular tensilon tests have also been reported in the Eaton-Lambert syndrome (Dell'Osso et al, 1983). The Eaton-Lambert syndrome commonly presents with ocular involvement (Burns et al, 2003)
Cranial nerve palsies - -such as 6th and 3rd nerve palsies usually affect a single eye as well as a subset of eye muscles.